bestunknownfacts.comJamestown, Virginia, holds a legendary place in American history. As the site of the first permanent English settlement in the New World, founded in 1607, it laid the foundation for what would one day become the United States. For many, it’s a source of pride, even ancestry. But not everything about Jamestown inspires patriotic nostalgia. In fact, some of what has been unearthed there is downright disturbing.
Archaeologists working at the site of the Jamestown colony have made several shocking discoveries—gruesome, mysterious, and tragic remnants that paint a far more complex picture of early colonial life. While Jamestown colony discoveries have helped us understand history, they’ve also revealed a chilling side of America’s origin story. Brace yourself as we dive into 10 of the eeriest finds dug up at Jamestown.
10. The Arrow in the Bone: A Young Boy’s Violent End
One of the first and most unsettling discoveries was that of a teenage boy, estimated to be around 14 or 15 years old. What made this find especially disturbing was the arrowhead embedded in his leg bone—a violent clue pointing to a deadly confrontation. Experts believe he was likely killed in a skirmish with the local Powhatan tribe, possibly just days after the settlers arrived.
Even more haunting was his burial: hastily done, in a shallow grave with no signs of ceremony or mourning. His body was positioned awkwardly, suggesting urgency and fear. Colonial records from leaders like John Smith mention the death of a young boy during those early days, but his name—and story—remain lost to history.
9. The Military Men Beneath the Church
Deep beneath the remains of Jamestown’s old church, archaeologists uncovered a grave that held four elite figures of the colony. They were interred with military precision, a sure sign of their status. DNA testing identified three of them: Captain Gabriel Archer, Reverend Robert Hunt, and Sir Ferdinando Wainman.
The fourth was 24-year-old Captain William West, who died in battle with the Powhatan. He was buried in a lavish silk sash adorned with silver fringe—fragments of which survived centuries underground. The effort made to honor him, even amid the chaos of frontier life, underscores both his importance and the heartbreak of his death.
8. The Mystery Knight’s Tomb
Of all the Jamestown colony discoveries, few have sparked as much mystery as the so-called knight’s tomb. The grave, marked by a black slab, was unlike others found in the area. Though speculation points to Sir George Yeardley—a knighted governor of Virginia—no one can say for sure who lies there.
Written records suggest Yeardley’s family wanted him buried in a black marble tomb. But there’s no family crest on the grave, and no direct proof connects him to the remains. Could it be him? Or someone else entirely? The identity of this medieval-style burial remains one of Jamestown’s strangest cold cases.
7. Scandal in the Soil: An Illegitimate Son
Not all discoveries are about bones and artifacts—some are about secrets. DNA analysis of remains found in the Jamestown church revealed a twisted family scandal. Two related skeletons shared a maternal line that puzzled historians. Further research unearthed a shocking truth: one of the dead men, Captain William West, was the illegitimate son of Thomas West, a colonial governor.
Worse still, William’s mother was Thomas’s own aunt. This revelation of incest would’ve been scandalous even by 17th-century standards. It’s believed the family fled to the New World to escape shame. While William went on to earn respect in Jamestown, the dark cloud of his origin hung quietly in the background—until modern science brought it into the light.
6. The Lost Ring of a Shakespearean Insider
One small but powerful artifact uncovered at Jamestown was a brass signet ring engraved with an eagle. It was traced back to the Strachey family, and possibly owned by William Strachey—an educated colonist and writer who sailed to Jamestown on the ill-fated Sea Venture.
Strachey’s harrowing account of that voyage is thought to have inspired Shakespeare’s The Tempest. While Strachey returned to England later in life, his ring stayed behind, lost—or perhaps stolen—during the colony’s darkest days. Finding it centuries later connected literature, tragedy, and exploration in a single eerie object.
5. Mass Graves Within the Fort
In the early days of Jamestown, death came quickly. Sickness, starvation, and the revolting hygiene conditions of the past tore through the fledgling settlement. The Virginia Company urged settlers to hide these grim realities from Native tribes—so instead of burying their dead outside the fort, they kept the bodies inside.
Excavations have revealed mass graves where multiple bodies were stacked together. Archaeologists found evidence of hurried burials, sometimes two or more people crammed into a single hole. John Smith’s journals referenced over 50 deaths during the first summer alone—but now, experts believe the real number may have been much higher.
4. Baby Shoes, Barely Worn
One heartbreaking find among the Jamestown colony discoveries was a tiny pair of goatskin leather shoes—belonging to a toddler who had barely begun to walk. The shoes were nearly pristine, suggesting they hadn’t been worn long before the child died.
No name, no grave marker—just a poignant reminder of a life cut tragically short.. The shoes were found in a well-turned dump site, buried with other discarded items. The child’s fate remains unknown, but the tiny shoes speak volumes about the human toll of colonial life.
3. Evidence of Cannibalism
Perhaps the most chilling Jamestown discovery of all was the skeletal remains of a 14-year-old girl known only as “Jane.” Her bones showed clear signs of butchering—marks made by knives, cleavers, and axes, all after death.
Historians believe this act took place during the brutal winter of 1609–1610, known as the “Starving Time,” when the desperate settlers resorted to cannibalism. Jane’s story shocked the nation when it was revealed, just like the notorious and disturbing historical figures who also haunt our past. And offered grim proof of how far the colonists were pushed to survive.
2. A Fort Built on Bones
While digging into the foundation of the original Jamestown fort, archaeologists discovered that the builders had used human remains as part of the structure’s base. Some bones had been crushed and mixed with clay and soil, likely to create more solid construction material.
It’s unknown whether this was done out of desperation or convenience—but it adds a macabre layer to Jamestown’s beginnings. The literal foundation of America’s first permanent colony may have been built upon the dead.
1. A Poisoning Plot?
Among the artifacts unearthed at Jamestown were strange chemical residues near the burial site of Captain Gabriel Archer. Archer had been part of a feud with John Smith and others in the colony, and his grave revealed something odd: a sealed silver box containing bone fragments and mysterious substances.
Historians now suspect Archer may have been part of a secret Catholic faction in a colony ruled by Protestants. Some even believe he was poisoned due to political betrayal and deadly conspiracies. The story remains murky, but the clues hint at deadly betrayal, buried for centuries.
Final Thoughts
The Jamestown colony discoveries are a fascinating and often unsettling glimpse into early American life. While history books paint a picture of perseverance and triumph, the archaeological record tells a more complicated story—one of loss, desperation, violence, and mystery. And as archaeologists continue to dig deeper, who knows what secrets still lie buried beneath Virginia’s soil—much like the mysterious ancient civilizations and their secrets?
Would you like me to create a matching Pinterest graphic or social share caption for this article?